Skip to content
← All notes

Notes

Google optimizes for the conversion you feed it

Every campaign that runs on Smart Bidding optimizes toward a conversion action. (Manual CPC, Target Impression Share, and Maximize Clicks do not; they chase clicks or placements, not conversions.) Most accounts set that conversion action without thinking about what it teaches Google. If your conversion is “form submitted,” Smart Bidding gets good at finding people who submit forms. Some of them buy. Many were never going to. The bidding is doing exactly what you told it, which is not the same as what you wanted.

Look closer and the people who submit your form are not one audience. Some are ready to buy now, and likely to within the month. Others are genuinely interested but months from deciding, the kind who need a lot more convincing before they pull the trigger. Both raised a hand, and both are worth reaching. They are not worth the same to your bidding, though. The slower group belongs in your middle and top of funnel work and your retargeting, where you stay in front of them until they are ready. What they should not be is the thing Smart Bidding optimizes on, because if you train it on people who are six months out, it learns to go and find more people who are six months out. The fix is to tell Google which conversions actually turned into business, and that means sending your real outcomes back into it.

What the bidding model is actually learning

Smart Bidding builds a picture of who is worth showing your ad to, and it builds that picture from one thing: the conversions you report. That signal is the target it aims at. Report a shallow signal and it optimizes to the shallow signal. Someone filling in a form is not someone who bought, and someone starting a free account is not someone who paid. Count those and you get more of those, in volume, at whatever quality the auction happens to include.

Smart Bidding finds more of whatever conversion you count Feed Google a form-submit conversion and it finds more form-fillers of mixed quality. Feed it closed deals with revenue and it finds more buyers. YOU COUNT BIDDING LEARNS YOU GET Form submitted Smart Bidding More form-fillers volume, mixed quality Closed deal + value Smart Bidding More buyers revenue
The bidding aims at the conversion you report. The lever is not the bid or the budget, it is which conversion you choose to count.

Close the loop with the GCLID

Google stamps every ad click with a GCLID, a unique identifier. Capture it in your form with a small snippet so it travels with the lead into your CRM, or even a spreadsheet. When a lead closes, you record which GCLID it was, whether it converted, and what it was worth. Then you upload that back into Google as a conversion, weekly at least. Now Google can connect the click it sold you to the revenue that click actually produced.

Set the closed-deal outcome up as its own conversion action, something like “lead closed,” and let it collect data alongside your existing one. Once enough closed leads have come through, you make it the primary action the bidding optimizes toward. From that point Smart Bidding is no longer chasing form fills. It is looking for the clicks that turn into paid, closed business. If you take calls, record them, rate them, and send that quality back the same way.

We have built our own endpoints for this, so the upload runs automatically from any CRM, for both call leads and form leads. You can build the same, run it through a spreadsheet, or use a third-party tool. What matters is that the data gets back to Google on a steady cadence, not how it gets there.

The GCLID round trip An ad click carries a GCLID, the form captures it, the CRM records whether the lead closed and its revenue, and you upload that back to Google so bidding optimizes for revenue. CLOSE THE LOOP WITH THE GCLID Ad click GCLID attached Form captures GCLID CRM closed? revenue? Upload weekly Bidding now optimizes for revenue, so the next click is a better one
The GCLID is what lets Google connect a click to a closed sale. Without the round trip, the bidding never learns which leads were real.

The edge brokers can’t copy and most advertisers don’t

This is also why a serious advertiser pulls ahead in an expensive market, and it works against two kinds of competitor at once.

The first is the lead broker. They generate a lead and sell it to five or ten buyers, which is how they survive high CPCs, but they never learn what happened to it. They do not know which leads closed or what any were worth, so the only thing they can optimize for is volume: more leads, any quality. They cannot close the loop, because the revenue is yours, not theirs.

The second is most of the field. The majority of advertisers never set up GCLID capture or offline conversions at all. Their tracking stops at the form fill, so their bidding optimizes for form fills, and they never learn which of those became customers. They could close the loop. They just don’t.

Either way, you end up in most auctions as the only bidder feeding closed deals and real revenue back into Google. That is not a niche trick. It is a durable advantage over nearly the whole field, and it compounds as the model learns.

Most of your competition never closes the loop Lead brokers cannot close the loop because they never see the revenue. Most advertisers do not, because they never set up GCLID or offline conversions. You close it, so only you can optimize for closed business. LEAD BROKER TYPICAL ADVERTISER YOU Can't close the loop Doesn't close the loop Closes the loop Sells the lead, never sees the revenue Never sets up GCLID or offline conversions Sees the revenue and feeds it back Optimizes for volume Optimizes for form fills Optimizes for closed business
Two of the three never close the loop: brokers can't, because the revenue is yours, and most advertisers simply never set it up. Feed closed deals back and you are often the only bidder in the auction optimizing for real business.

How to set it up

Start with the plumbing, because none of this works without it. Get the GCLID captured in your forms and a call tracker on your phone numbers, so every lead carries its source. Then:

  • Record outcomes where the money is decided, in your CRM. Tag each lead with whether it closed and what it was worth. This is the data Google never sees on its own.
  • Upload weekly, not occasionally. Stale uploads starve the model. Google gives you a template, and you hash your first-party data before sending it.
  • Promote the new conversion action without losing your learning. Keep your current action as primary and add “lead closed” as a secondary one that collects in parallel, with both firing. Once it has enough data, switch it to primary. Swap too early and you reset the bidding model for nothing.

Do this and the goal you are optimizing stops being “get more leads” and becomes “get more leads that close.” That is the version worth paying for, and it is the one Google will happily chase once you show it which leads were real.